Let me tell you the things that you’d need to know, before I finally go ahead and change my course. Once and for all, my words will make immortal the feelings you alone have awaken in me.
I love you way too much already it’s hurting me not to see any future with you. Your love is too beautiful I cannot touch it. It shows me such a striking contrast of what I cannot have, too much that it blinds me. I cannot stay friends with you while nursing such desire too intense it scares me. And I cannot stay in love with you while we are nurturing such a beautiful friendship I know I won’t find with any other else.
Why do I love you, anyway? Should I even answer that? There’s something that I cannot name that stirred in me from the day that I first saw you. There’s something that both frightened and delighted me that night you first called me, a year ago. I guess I will die wondering what that was. I love you simply because of that mystery. There was something in your eyes that got hold of my soul, taking with it all reason I had left.
You are everything that I would want to be with for the rest of my life. But I cannot keep loving you the way that you would be pleased to, because you will break my heart, like you already had done before. Call me stupid, stubborn. Call me anything else. But I choose to keep thinking that way, I choose to get hurt more from that thought, because the more that I get hurt, the more that I become less frightened to get into the night forest all by myself.
My night forest is this marriage, and I am staying while I can. I am not going away, because I cannot bear to leave you. I cannot bear to hurt you. I cannot bear the thought that soon after your crying over me, you will move on, and find yet another. I am staying, but I should stop giving myself to you. Because each time I do, you take away a huge piece of me. Right now, there’s almost nothing left.
There is so much fear. I am almost certain that we got the same fears. All we both want is for each other to stay in sight. But are we really going anywhere?
I want out of this quagmire and I realized I cannot hold on to you because you too are stuck, here, with me. I want both of us out…Your daughter, her eyes…they pierced through me. It helped to finally see her in person. It reminded me where your life should be headed. Each time you talk about your wife, how much you love her, how much you take care of her, I die deep inside. And believing in how much you feel for me becomes impossibly difficult. How could I trust the same person who betrays his wife?
I love you. I hope you realize how much difficult this is for me. If I stop going out with you, whatever you show your family will be genuine once again. I am giving you that freedom. And I can move on and learn to find healing for all the scars loving too much have left me.
I have spoken too much already. I guess it’s time for me rediscover the silence where my soul resides. I’ll start again, from there…